Levitt's Abortion results disappeared when programming Error Fixed
"The Boston Fed's Mr. Foote says he spotted a missing formula in the programming oversight of Mr. Levitt's original research. He argues that the programming oversight made it difficult to pick up other factors that might have influenced crime rates during the 1980s and 1990s . . . . He also argues that Levitt should have counted arrests on a per-capita basis. Instead, he coundted overall arrests. After he adjusted for both factors, Mr. Foote says, the abortion effect disappeared.
Christopher L. Foote and Christopher F. Goetz's paper can be found here. Personally, I think calling this a "programming oversight" is being much too nice (See my post here to see an example of what you would have to miss to not notice whether you have used fixed effects). More importantly everyone who works with panel data knows that you use fixed effects.
My own work concentrated on murder rates, but I also included fixed effects. Donohue and Levitt never provided us with all their data or their regressions and would never answer any questions that we had so I just assumed that they had included fixed effects from the beginning. It would have been nice if they had provided us with this same information years ago.
My paper with John Whitley is available here.
A letter that I had in the WSJ is available here.
James Q. Wilson's review of this debate is available here.
UPDATE:
See also Steve Sailer's past work on this topic.
See also Steve Sailer's compliation of what others are saying here.
UPDATE II (I have been asked about inaccurate claims regarding my own research in More Guns, Less Crime):
See this for a discussion about claimed errors in More Guns, Less Crime
Christopher L. Foote and Christopher F. Goetz's paper can be found here. Personally, I think calling this a "programming oversight" is being much too nice (See my post here to see an example of what you would have to miss to not notice whether you have used fixed effects). More importantly everyone who works with panel data knows that you use fixed effects.
My own work concentrated on murder rates, but I also included fixed effects. Donohue and Levitt never provided us with all their data or their regressions and would never answer any questions that we had so I just assumed that they had included fixed effects from the beginning. It would have been nice if they had provided us with this same information years ago.
My paper with John Whitley is available here.
A letter that I had in the WSJ is available here.
James Q. Wilson's review of this debate is available here.
UPDATE:
See also Steve Sailer's past work on this topic.
See also Steve Sailer's compliation of what others are saying here.
UPDATE II (I have been asked about inaccurate claims regarding my own research in More Guns, Less Crime):
See this for a discussion about claimed errors in More Guns, Less Crime
Related Posts
New Research that Abortion Increases Violent Crime Gets AttentionFrom today's Chicago Sun Times:A high-profile economist is challenging the conclusion in the best-selling book Freakono- White House tries to pressure Stupak to be quite about Abortion language in Senate Health BillCNSnews has this:Rep. Bart Stupak (D-Mich.) said the White House and the Democratic leadership in the House of Represen
- Damage from UK riots put at $324 millionThe Financial Times has this:The interests of government and business have coincided neatly over the costs of riot dama
- Remember how Chicago murder rate fell last year? Well, don't look to arrests for murder being the cause"Only 30 Percent Of Last Year’s Murders Have Been Solved"Murders in Chicago were down last year, but it’s a different s
- Ariel Rubinstein Reviews FreakonomicsAriel Rubinstein provides a critical review of Freakonomics. I guess that I had wish that Ariel had gotten more into t
- A note on justice in the US and EuropeFrom the Economist magazine:. . . Beyond such differences in legal cultures, one fact is inescapable. In America a mode
Levitt's Abortion "Disappeared" When "Programming" Error Fixed
4/
5
Oleh
abudzar
